Should European Publishers create and own a Premium Exchange Platform?

Scope

Publishers are increasingly dependent on online advertising revenues as a source of income. When looking at the types of online advertising inventory, different studies have observed that the premium inventory, defined as the inventory sold by publishers themselves, is responsible for the large majority of the revenue (> 75%), although it represents only a small part of the available inventory (<10%).

For publishers it is therefore key to maximize their premium digital inventory.
This inventory is considered as ‘brand-safe’ and is mainly used for high value brand advertising.

On an aggregated level, there is a major discrepancy between time spent and money spent on different media (as shown in a Morgan Stanley study from 2010, slide 25/53). There is an overspending on traditional media (tv/print) compared to the time spend on these media.
Buyers and advertisers should be able to spend more brand advertising money online, but an inefficient buying process is creating a barrier for this money to flow into the digital market.
When buying brand campaigns on “traditional media”, buyers can reach large audiences per buy, often facilitated by a media specific market place or buying platform. When buying brand campaigns online though, buyers are confronted with a scattered supply side and a complex buying process. This ‘market inefficiency’ is withholding buyers to spend brand budgets online, hence the major discrepancy between time and money spend on the different media.

To solve this market inefficiency, a marketplace / buying platform dedicated to brand-safe inventory should be created. This platform will allow media buyers to reach large audience per buy and this will result in more brand advertising budget flowing into the digital market.

The buying platform solution is not new. It is extensively used on the remnant inventory (inventory not sold by the publishers themselves). There have been tremendous tech investments in this space, resulting in trading desks, DSP’s, SSP’s, ad networks, ad exchanges,…
These technologies allow publishers to dispose of remnant inventory and advertisers to buy very specific parts of publisher’s inventory at heavily discounted rates.

There is a clear consolidation movement going on in the remnant tech space. Companies like WPP, Publicis and Google are making strategic acquisitions ensuring them the access to inventory and ensuring them a vast part of the digital advertising revenue. They are trying to lock the end-to-end process chain and strengthen their grip on the market.

These companies and technologies are moving up the inventory funnel, forcing publishers to provide access to their premium inventory at heavily discounted prices and slowly eroding cpm prices. This could have a destabilizing effect on the publisher industry.

So where does this leave the publisher?

In the current eco-system, publishers have very little weight in the power balance. They risk becoming bystanders in an industry where they should play a leading role.

A publisher owned and operated marketplace / buying platform would ensure the industry that the pricing level, the technology, the inventory and the future of the platform is validated by the participating publishers, safeguarding the industry’s best interest.

Why should European publisher participate?

-          It’s time for publisher to (re)claim power in the eco system
The industry should protect itself from the increasing concentration of power on the demand side of the market.

-          Using the platform will grant access to new revenue
As previously stated, this will level out the unbalance between time and money spend and seriously increase publishers premium ad revenue.

-          Operating the platform is a profitable business

How can Adlogix help ?

We are convinced that the existing inefficiency will be solved by a marketplace dedicated to the premium digital advertising inventory. Such a solution would benefit the advertisers and the publishers.

Due to the nature of the inventory sold on the marketplace – premium digital inventory – this marketplace must provide guarantees on the inventory it serves.

The premium digital buying process is indeed driven by guarantees that need to be given to the buyers.

-          The  duration of the campaign,
-          the budget,
-          the format and
-          the placement.

Buyers and advertisers buying premium inventory on the platform will require these guarantees as this is the essence of the premium inventory.

This is where the complexity lays for solving the above market inefficiency: creating a marketplace for premium digital inventory requires a deep integration with the inventory of the participating publishers. We can provide this integration with our inventory management and process optimization solution, Adlogix.

Summarized

It is in the strategic interest of publishers to co-own a premium exchange platform. This will create a more balanced power play in the digital advertising eco-system and ensure publishers to have control over pricing, data and technology, while providing advertisers an efficient buying process for brand-safe inventory.

We would love to hear you opinion about this, don’t hesitate to contact us.

____________________________________________________________________

About Adlogix :
Adlogix is an online advertising resource management solution. It works in conjunction with our clients’ ad server and allows them to streamline the process of selling and managing premium online advertising space.  We integrate data from any ad server (OAS, DART, HELIOS IQ, Atlas,….), but also from other legacy systems (SAP, Dynamics, …).

We help our clients – mostly large publishers and publisher networks – to integrate the process of selling premium online advertising space with their overall business process.
We provide them the tools to accurately manage and sell their inventory of available advertising positions and to optimize their operational flows.
Sales teams can easily create and follow up campaigns, while ad operations teams benefit from automated campaign trafficking.

This process optimization results directly in revenue maximization and cost minimization.

Summarized:

  • Sales & Order Process management
  • Inventory management (sold & unsold inventory)
  • Management Business reporting tools
  • Campaign trafficking tools
  • Complementary to ad server solution, integratable with legacy systems (CRM, billing,…)

Need more information?  Go to our website www.adlogix.eu or contact us.

Active Inventory Management

Adlogix is a solution provider to the online publishing industry, more specifically providing a process optimization solution for the premium digital advertising sales and operation cycle.

We are often confronted with the complexity of explaining the true central nervous system of Adlogix’ solution: the Active Inventory Management.

Just to be clear, in this article we are not talking about the inventory management capabilities or functionalities of the ad server, but rather the inventory capabilities inside Adlogix. This is very different since Adlogix’s Active Inventory Management also takes into account sales data (offers, options, reservations…) and therefore has a better view of your future inventory availabilities.
Adlogix has a two way connection with the ad server, import historical traffic data and export confirmed campaign parameters (program the ad server).

To fully understand the capabilities of our Active Inventory Management, we’ll start by describing what the traditional and current solutions provide in the field of online advertising operations management and more specifically in the area of inventory management.

The “Spreadsheet Method”

In the “traditional” online advertising sales cycle, sales teams would maintain a spreadsheet, showing what products where available for sale in a given period. This spreadsheet would be updated weekly or monthly, based on the ad server statistics and based on the products available for sale.
No need to say this was (is) disastrous on a point of view of inventory management.  At best, this might give you an indication of what you could eventually sell in a static, linear environment.
Forget scalability, forget transparency, forget efficiency. Forget inventory management all together.
Hello over-deliveries and under-deliveries, hello operational headaches.


Sales and process management software

As digital advertising revenue becomes a more and more strategic revenue driver for many publishers, they start investing in sales and process management software. This software helps publishers to streamline the process from sales to revenue collection. There are a few “pure players” in this market and many more cross-over solutions like customized crm tools, systems created initially for other media or in-house built applications. These solutions do improve the operational efficiency of the overall process as they are a certain improvement compared to the spreadsheet based method.  While some of the proposed solutions focus on the pure sales/crm functionalities others are more post-sales or contract management oriented. The “non-pure players” however, often solve some of the apparent problems of one team (often sales), while pushing the real process problems to the next team in the process (often adops).


The “pure players”: first generation

The “pure players”, which are the solutions build from the ground up dedicated to the digital advertising process, tend to provide an end to end solution, from sales to revenue collection. The goal is to assist the different departments in the digital advertising eco system to execute their jobs, automate where possible and remove data duplication and data redundancy. The “pure solution” is an ERP dedicated to the digital advertising eco system, it’s connected to your ad server, billing system, crm, BI,…

One of the core competences of such a “pure player solution” should be inventory management.
If you want to be able to optimize your revenue and your process, you need to have a good visibility and excellent management capabilities of the products you can sell; which constitutes your inventory.
The major problem here is the complexity this involves. Digital advertising is a dynamic environment and there are many different types of products to manage. Your “stock” of available ad impressions for sale is not a certified value and it changes from day to day, impacting your product delivery capabilities.

First generation pure player solutions have made good progress improving the process and inventory management capabilities. They tackle the inventory problem as a 2 dimensional problem, where the challenge is to fill a pre-defined inventory volume with pre-defined products.

Sort of like the Tetris game. Every Tetris block represents a product and the goal is to fill the Tetris canvas with as many products as possible.

This also shows the weakness of this model: it is static. It often assumes that the total available volume (the Tetris canvas) is fixed over a period of time (day, week) and it operates in a model where once the products are sold, they no longer change their inventory occupancy. In the Tetris analogy, once the blocks are dropped, their position and size doesn’t change during the rest of the game.

This operating model however, does not come close to the reality of inventory usage and inventory distribution in the digital advertising industry.
First of all, the reality is that the inventory volume (the Tetris canvas) changes every day and there is no way to have a 100% certitude about tomorrows inventory volume. So you need to be able to manage your inventory assuming that every new day will be different and will impact your inventory usage calculations. More importantly, products might have different priorities that need to be respected during delivery; this obviously impacts your inventory allocation. This also means that your product’s inventory occupancy will change over time as new products (with higher or lower priorities) are sold or if your delivery behaves differently than initially expected (more or less delivery on a certain day).  In the Tetris analogy, once the blocks are dropped (the products are sold), the canvas size will change (the inventory will change) daily and therefor the position and size of the blocks will have to change accordingly (your calculated product delivery patters will have to adapt to product priorities and the available inventory)!


Second generation : Active Inventory Management

This is where Adlogix’ Active Inventory Management comes in. Adlogix constantly recalculates the available inventory taking into account, product priority, product type, actual delivery….
This means that if you sell a product, Adlogix will recalculate the inventory usage of all products with a lower priority than the one you just sold, to ensure the delivery of all these products is still possible or to visualize eventual expected delivery problems in the future.
This also means that if, for some reason, the actual delivery of a product is not as expected in the initial calculations, Adlogix will calculate the impact of this delivery delta over the remaining campaign period and over all other campaigns that are impacted by this.

In the Tetris example, our Active Inventory Management would be the software allowing you to play and win a 3D-Tetris game, where the 3D Tetris canvas/box would constantly change shape and the player would have an infinite number of custom shaped blocks to fill the ever changing shape of the Tetris box.

The net result of Active Inventory Management is revenue optimization, inventory maximization, visibility and assurance.

This is true inventory management as it should be. It helps you to harvest the revenue potential of your inventory, as it allows you to accurately manage your inventory availabilities and it allows you to anticipate possible inventory problems.
This means your clients, the advertisers, will be served better what ultimately leads to even more advertising money flowing to your company.

This is what we see happening with our clients.

Active Inventory Management is the only form of inventory management that will allow you, as a digital publisher, to prepare for the future.  It is a matter of getting close to reality and the digital advertising reality is surely not representable by a spreadsheet nor a two dimensional Tetris board.
If you have any questions about this topic or if you would like more information about Adlogix, please contact us via our website or call our office  : + 32 2 400 75 00

____________________________________________________________________

About Adlogix :
Adlogix is an online advertising resource management solution. It works in conjunction with our clients’ ad server and allows them to streamline the process of selling and managing premium online advertising space.  We integrate data from any ad server (OAS, DART, HELIOS IQ, Atlas,….), but also from other legacy systems (SAP, Dynamics, …).

We help our clients – mostly large publishers and publisher networks – to integrate the process of selling premium online advertising space with their overall business process.
We provide them the tools to accurately manage and sell their inventory of available advertising positions and to optimize their operational flows.
Sales teams can easily create and follow up campaigns, while ad operations teams benefit from automated campaign trafficking.

This process optimization results directly in revenue maximization and cost minimization.

Summarized:

  • Sales & Order Process management
  • Inventory management (sold & unsold inventory)
  • Management Business reporting tools
  • Campaign trafficking tools
  • Complementary to ad server solution, integratable with legacy systems (CRM, billing,…)

Need more information?  Go to our website www.adlogix.eu or contact us.

____________________________________________________________________